The Hamptons, a picturesque destination, offers more than just stunning beaches and luxurious estates. Coffee enthusiasts know that finding the perfect coffee shop can elevate any visit. The charm of small-town cafes adds to the unique experience. Exploring the top coffee shops in this region promises delightful brews and cozy atmospheres.
Top Coffee Shops by Location
East Hampton
Jack's Stir Brew Coffee
Jack's Stir Brew Coffee in East Hampton offers a unique coffee experience. The patented Stir Brewer method extracts the fullest flavor from each bean. Jack's Stir Brew Coffee became New York City's first 100% organic coffee shop and vegan bakery. The cozy atmosphere invites visitors to savor every sip. The Amagansett and Sag Harbor locations also attract many coffee lovers.
Tutto Café
Tutto Café in East Hampton brings a touch of Italy to the Hamptons. The café serves organic coffee with a Neapolitan accent. The founders, Gianapaolo de Felice and David Mayer, spent over a year perfecting their coffee craft. Tutto Café offers delicious pastries, paninis, and savories. The upscale ambiance makes it a perfect spot to unwind.
Southampton
The Golden Pear
The Golden Pear in Southampton has been a staple since 1987. The café offers freshly brewed coffee and a vibrant atmosphere. The outdoor seating provides a great view for people-watching. The Golden Pear also serves a variety of delicious eats. The Bridgehampton and East Hampton locations are equally popular.
Hampton Coffee Company
Hampton Coffee Company started in Water Mill in 1994. The company now boasts six locations across the Hamptons. The menu includes hot breakfast, lunch items, and specialty drinks. Monthly specialty food and drink items keep the offerings fresh. The app allows customers to order ahead and collect rewards.
Montauk
Left Hand Montauk Coffee Company
Left Hand Montauk Coffee Company opened its doors in 2015. The locally owned roaster serves coffee named after historical places and surf spots. The beans come from well-known surf destinations around the world. The Lighthouse Espresso and Camp Hero Medium Roast are popular choices. The coffee culture at Left Hand Montauk Coffee Company attracts both locals and visitors.
Westhampton Beach
Caffeine in Westhampton Beach serves La Colombe coffee daily. The café offers creative blends and draft lattes. The menu includes an array of teas and bakery items. Non-dairy alternatives like pistachio milk add a unique touch. Cozy seating by the windows allows for people-watching while enjoying a cup of coffee.
Sag Harbor
Grindstone Coffee & Donuts in Sag Harbor has become a staple since 2016. The café is famous for its freshly made donuts. Each donut takes a minimum of 48 hours to create. The coffee menu features espresso, drip, and cold brew options. The honey lavender latte stands out as a popular choice. The friendly atmosphere and excellent customer service enhance the experience.
Jack's Stir Brew Coffee also has a location in Sag Harbor. The patented Stir Brewer method ensures full flavor extraction. Jack's offers 100% organic coffee and vegan bakery items. The cozy ambiance invites visitors to relax and enjoy their drinks.
Amagansett
Hampton Coffee Company in Amagansett remains a favorite among locals. The café offers a variety of breakfast and lunch items. Specialty drinks and monthly food items keep the menu exciting. The app allows customers to order ahead and collect rewards. The welcoming atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for coffee lovers.
Sagtown Coffee in Sag Harbor excels in crafting the perfect espresso. The café uses La Colombe roasts, ensuring a rich and robust flavor. The baristas at Sagtown Coffee master the art of pulling espresso shots. The cozy interior and outdoor seating provide a comfortable environment. The menu also includes draft lattes and cold brews. Each visit promises an exceptional espresso experience.
Best for Pastries
Grindstone Coffee & Donuts
Grindstone Coffee & Donuts in Sag Harbor offers a delightful combination of coffee and pastries. The café's donuts take 48 hours to create, ensuring freshness and quality. The honey lavender latte pairs perfectly with these treats. The friendly staff and inviting atmosphere enhance the experience. Grindstone Coffee & Donuts has become a staple for both locals and visitors. The café's commitment to quality makes it one of the top coffee shops in the Hamptons.
Best for Ambiance
Java Nation
Java Nation in Bridgehampton provides a unique and welcoming ambiance. The café features local art, leather couches, and a large roaster. The industrial-looking space adds to the charm. Java Nation serves a variety of coffee blends, each crafted with care. The location near the Bridgehampton train station attracts a loyal crowd. The cozy setting makes it an ideal spot to relax and enjoy a cup of coffee.
The Hamptons offer a treasure trove of coffee gems. Jack's Stir Brew Coffee, Tutto Café, The Golden Pear, Hampton Coffee Company, Left Hand Montauk Coffee Company, Caffeine, Grindstone Coffee & Donuts, and Java Nation each bring something special to the table. Coffee enthusiasts should explore these spots and discover personal favorites. The coffee culture in the Hamptons thrives on local charm and quality brews. Each visit promises a unique and delightful experience.
